Summary: The volume is full of thought-provoking insight which will prove a stimulus both to further study and to scholarly disagreement.
Edition/Copyright: 69 Cover: Paperback Publisher: Torchbooks Published: 09/28/1972 International: No
View Sample Chapter
1. If you do know that here is one hand,1 we'll grant you all the rest. When one says that such and such a proposition can't be proved, of course that does not mean that it can't be derived from other propositions; any proposition can be derived from other ones. But they may be no more certain than it is itself. (On this a curious remark by H. Newman.)
2. From its seeming to me--or to everyone--to be so, it doesn't follow that it is so. What we can ask is whether it can make sense to doubt it.
3. If e.g. someone says ''I don't know if there's a hand here'' he might be told ''Look closer''.--This possibility of satisfying oneself is part of the language-game. Is one of its essential features.
4. ''I know that I am a human being.'' In order to see how unclear the sense of this proposition is, consider its negation. At most it might be taken to mean ''I know I have the organs of a human''. (E.g. a brain which, after all, no one has ever yet seen.) But what about such a proposition as ''I know I have a brain''? Can I doubt it? Grounds for doubt are lacking! Everything speaks in its favour, nothing against it. Nevertheless it is imaginable that my skull should turn out empty when it was operated on.
5. Whether a proposition can turn out false after all depends on what I make count as determinants for that proposition.
6. Now, can one enumerate what one knows (like Moore)? Straight off like that, I believe not.--For otherwise the expression ''I know'' gets misused. And through this misuse a queer and extremely important mental state seems to be revealed.
7. My life shews that I know or am certain that there is a chair over there, or a door, and so on.--I tell a friend e.g. ''Take that chair over there'', ''Shut the door'', etc. etc.
8. The difference between the concept of 'knowing' and the concept of 'being certain' isn't of any great importance at all, except where ''I know'' is meant to mean: I can't be wrong. In a law-court, for example, ''I am certain'' could replace ''I know'' in every piece of testimony. We might even imagine its being forbidden to say ''I know'' there. [A passage in Wilhelm Meister, where ''You know'' or ''You knew'' is used in the sense ''You were certain'', the facts being different from what he knew.]
9. Now do I, in the course of my life, make sure I know that here is a hand--my own hand, that is?
10. I know that a sick man is lying here? Nonsense! I am sitting at his bedside, I am looking attentively into his face.-So I don't know, then, that there is a sick man lying here? Neither the question nor the assertion makes sense. Any more than the assertion ''I am here'', which I might yet use at any moment, if suitable occasion presented itself.--Then is ''2 x 2 = 4'' nonsense in the same way, and not a proposition of arithmetic, apart from particular occasions? '' 2 x 2 = 4'' is a true proposition of arithmetic-not ''on particular occasions'' nor ''always'' but the spoken or written sentence ''2 x 2. = 4'' in Chinese might have a different meaning or be out and out nonsense, and from this is seen that it is only in use that the proposition has its sense. And ''I know that there's a sick man lying here'', used in an unsuitable situation, seems not to be nonsense but rather seems matter-of-course, only because one can fairly easily imagine a situation to fit it, and one thinks that the words ''I know that . . . '' are always in place where there is no doubt, and hence even where the expression of doubt would be unintelligible.
11. We just do not see how very specialized the use of ''I know'' is.
12. --For ''I know'' seems to describe a state of affairs which guarantees what is known, guarantees it as a fact. One always forgets the expression ''I thought I knew''.
13. For it is not as though the proposition ''It is so'' could be inferred from someone else's utterance: ''I know it is so''. Nor from the utterance together with its not being a lie.--But can't I infer ''It is so'' from my own utterance ''I know etc.''? Yes; and also ''There is a hand there'' follows from the proposition ''He knows that there's a hand there''. But from his utterance ''I know . . . '' it does not follow that he does know it.
14. That he does know takes some shewing.
15. It needs to be shewn that no mistake was possible. Giving the assurance ''I know'' doesn't suffice. For it is after all only an assurance that I can't be making a mistake, and it needs to be objectively established that I am not making a mistake about that.
16. ''If I know something, then I also know that I know it , etc.'' amounts to: ''I know that'' means ''I am incapable of being wrong about that''. But whether I am so needs to be established objectively.
17. Suppose now I say ''I'm incapable of being wrong about this: that is a book'' while I point to an object. What would a mistake here be like? And have I any clear idea of it?
18. ''I know'' often means: I have the proper grounds for my statement. So if the other person is acquainted with the language game, he would admit that I know. The other, if he is acquainted with the language-game, must be able to imagine how, one may know something of the kind.
''The seventh volume of the Wittgenstein corpus, which contains notes written at the end of his life.... Provides a straightforward guide to the thought of this most complex of philosophers.''
''The volume is full of thought-provoking insights which will prove a stimulus both to further study and to scholarly disagreement.''
-- Alan R. White, Philosophical Books
''All students of philosophy will want to read it. What it contains is his notes on knowledge and doubt, written in the last year and a half of his life, mainly in answer to G. E. Moore's articles on these subjects. ''
Scranton, PA, U.S.A. 1972 Soft cover Good Book. 8vo-over 7?-9?" tall. Original publisher's soft covers. Parallel translation, with German and English on facing pages. Slight wear and toning to edges...show more. Otherwise a clean, tight and unmarked book. Very neat. ...show less
$11.24 +$3.99 s/h
Book Culture Inc. New York, NY
1972 Paperback Good Shipped from a real independent book store in Manhattan.
$16.00 +$3.99 s/h
SLO Books CA San Luis Obispo, CA
Good with no dust jacket; Soft; Harper Perennial; 1972 0061316865. 0.6 x 7.7 x 5.2 Inches; 192 pages.
$22.72 +$3.99 s/h
Big Planet Books Burbank, CA
1972-09-06 Paperback Good Expedited shipping is available for this item!
$22.99 +$3.99 s/h
SUPER BOOKS Fort Mill, SC
Buy with Confidence. Excellent Customer Support. We ship from multiple US locations. No CD, DVD or Access Code Included.
Free Shipping Get Free Shipping on orders over $25 (not including Rental and Marketplace). Order arrives in 5-10 business days.
Need it faster? We offer fast, flat-rate expedited shipping options.
Not the right book for you? We'll gladly take it back within 30 days.
To return an eTextbook:
Your eTextbook is non-returnable once it's been activated. You must contact us about returning your eTextbook before you activate it.
Returns are accepted within 30 days of the purchase date on your order confirmation.
This book qualifies for guaranteed cash back! Buy it now for , then:
Sell it back by:
Guaranteed cash back:
Cost of this book after cash back:
Take advantage of Guaranteed Cash Back. Send your book to us in good condition before the end of the buyback period, we'll send YOU a check, and you'll pay less for your textbooks!
If you find this book for less on Amazon.com (direct from Amazon, not marketplace sellers), we'll match it.
In our warehouse, waiting to ship directly to you.
We hand-inspect every used textbook to make sure it's in good condition.
Buy it now. Sell it later!
Sell this textbook for cash!
When you're done with this book, sell it back to Textbooks.com. In addition to the the best possible buyback price, you'll get an extra 10% cash back just for being a customer.
We buy good-condition used textbooks year 'round, 24/7. No matter where you bought it, Textbooks.com will buy your textbooks for the most cash.
We hand-inspect every one of our used textbooks to ensure good condition.
Our used textbooks do NOT have:
Missing or torn pages
Missing or torn cover
Torn or damaged binding
A broken spine
This textbook has never been used.
Due to the size of eTextbooks, a high-speed internet connection (cable modem, DSL, LAN) is required for download stability and speed. Your connection can be wired or wireless.
Being online is not required for reading an eTextbook after successfully downloading it. You must only be connected to the Internet during the download process.
Windows XP, Windows Vista or Mac OS X 10.3 or above
At least 280 MB RAM, a 600 mHZ processor and 110 MB of hard drive space
1024x768 (or larger) screen resolution
What is the Marketplace? It's another way for you to get the right price on the books you need. We approved every Marketplace vendor to sell their books on Textbooks.com, so you know they're all reliable.
What are Marketplace shipping options? Marketplace items do not qualify for free shipping. When ordering from the Marketplace, please specify whether you want the seller to send your book Standard ($3.99/item) or Express ($6.99/item). To get free shipping over $25, just order directly from Textbooks.com instead of through the Marketplace.
FREE UPS 2nd Day Air Terms
Rental and Marketplace items are excluded. Offer is valid from 1/21/2013 12:00PM to 1/23/2013 11:59AM CST. Your order must be placed by 12 Noon CST to be processed on the same day. Minimum order value is $100.00 excluding Rental and Marketplace items. To redeem this offer, select "FREE UPS 2ND DAY AIR" at checkout. Offer not is not valid on previous orders.
Compared to the prices of new and used, sold directly from Amazon.com (not marketplace sellers). If you find Amazon.com directly selling the textbook for a lower price, WE'LL MATCH IT...GUARANTEED. details